Public Workspaces

Title Approval of 50i87r2 Output Repeatability
Description
Draft 2 of NSF/ANSI 50 issue 87 is being forwarded to the Joint Committee for balloting. Please review the changes proposed to this standard and submit your ballot by August 8, 2013 via the NSF Online Workspace. THIS IS A 2-WEEK BALLOT.

Purpose

The purpose of this ballot is to replace the current repeatability variance for each output measurement to a 10% limit on the average of the 5 repeatability measurements at both 50% and 100% output.

Revision 2 addresses comments received from the revision 1 ballot on how to calculate the variance of each output rate from the average output rate for the 50% and 100% tests. This two-week adjudication ballot also addresses one unresolved negative comment that was received stating the calculation was not clear; revision 2 addresses the comment; however the commenter did not accept the response. 

This ballot allows voters the opportunity to change or reaffirm their vote based on the content of the comments contained herein. 

Voting options:

1.	Affirmative: you are voting to accept the ballot document as it stands after your consideration of the unresolved negative comments.
2.	Negative: You are voting to reject the ballot document as it stands after your consideration of the unresolved negative comments. Voters who change an affirmative to a negative shall cite the unresolved negative comment that caused their decision.  
3.	Abstain: You do not feel that you have sufficient information to make an informed decision on this issue. 

Please note that if you do not return a vote in this adjudication ballot, your original vote will remain in effect.  

At the close of this adjudication ballot, all results will be tallied to determine if the requirements for consensus have been satisfied.
Ballot Options Ballot has closed
[ ] Affirmative
[ ] Negative
[ ] Abstain
Document for Approval 50i87r2 Output Repeatability .pdf
Opening Date Thu, Jul 25 2013 9:30 am Eastern Daylight Time
Closing Date Thu, Aug 8 2013 11:59 pm Eastern Daylight Time
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items

Name Type Date Actions

02470: Approval of 50i87r2 Output Repeatability

Document (Archive)

2013-08-09

No Access

2012 JC meeting summary excerpt -Annex G.pdf

Document

2013-07-23

No Access

DiGiovanni-Purkiss-Vyles - Response letter negative comment 50i87r1(2).pdf

Document

2013-07-23

No Access

JC memo 50i87r2 and adjudication.pdf

Document

2013-07-23

No Access

RWF-2012-3 Output Test Repeatability.pdf

Document

2013-07-23

No Access