Public Workspaces

Title Approval of ADJ53i91r1 et al -filter plugging
Description
This is an adjudication ballot for the proposed revision to address premature clogging of filters during testing and to clarify what is and is not allowed with regards to pre-filtering the challenge water of products if requested by the manufacturer.  

One unresolved negative vote was submitted on the Technical Committee ballot by Dr. Jamie Bartram, who stated his opinion that a system that clogs prematurely should be cause for failure. 

This two-week ballot allows voters the opportunity to respond, change or reaffirm their vote based on the content of the comments contained herein. In the reference items for this ballot, included is the response letter to the comment from the one negative vote not resolved. 

Voting options:

1.	Affirmative: you are voting to accept the ballot document as it stands after your consideration of the unresolved negative comments.
2.	Negative: You are voting to reject the ballot document as it stands after your consideration of the unresolved negative comments. Voters who change an affirmative to a negative shall cite the unresolved negative comment that caused their decision.  
3.	Abstain: You do not feel that you have sufficient information to make an informed decision on this issue. 

Please note that if you do not return a vote in this adjudication ballot, your original vote will remain in effect.
Ballot Options Ballot has closed
[ ] Affirmative
[ ] Negative
[ ] Abstain
Document for Approval Combined ADJ53i91r1 & JC memo.pdf
Opening Date Tue, Nov 5 2013 9:30 am Eastern Standard Time
Closing Date Tue, Nov 19 2013 11:59 pm Eastern Standard Time
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items

Name Type Date Actions

02588: Approval of ADJ53i91r1 et al -filter plugging

Document (Archive)

2013-11-20

No Access

2011 DWTU JC meeting summary excerpt-filter plugging.pdf

Document

2013-11-05

No Access

2013 DWTU JC meeting summary excerpt-filter plugging.pdf

Document

2013-11-05

No Access

Ellison-Sauerbier-Bartram Response letter -53i91r1 et al 2013 11 01.pdf

Document

2013-11-05

No Access