Public Workspaces

Title STRAW BALLOT for NSF 391.1 – Economic or Governance
Description
Please vote on all three (3) ballots 

Ballot # 1: Do you approve of the recommendation that the Economic Section should be changed to Governance?

NSF 391.1 shall adopt the following model Environmental Social Governance (ESG) model instead of the current model of Environmental Social Economic (ESE). ESG is commonly used within the sustainability and CSR sectors. While there are many instances where ESE is the default set of categories, there are as many references to ESG, including seminal work done by the World Bank.



Ballot# 2: Do you approve that the Economic Section should remain and shall not be changed?

NSF 391.1 will continue to follow the current model of Environmental Social Economic (ESE).“The economic dimension of sustainability reporting concerns the organization’s impacts on the economic conditions of its stakeholders and on economic systems at local, national and global levels.” This definition suggests that this ‘economic’ category of sustainability relates to conditions pertaining to the organization’s stakeholders, rather than the financial or “profitability” condition of the organization itself.  This “outward facing” aspect of the standard, as with the other aspects, pertains to stakeholders – not inward toward itself.  There is common tissue between the three categories of the triple bottom line.  



Ballot #3: Do you approve the recommendation of combining both Economic and Governance as one section. The new section will be changed to Economic and Governance.

NSF 391.1 will continue to follow the current model of Environmental Social Economic (ESE), but will include governance within this section. As such, including the word governance in the category heading acknowledges that for the professional services organization, governance is a critical and significant pillar.
Ballot Options Ballot has closed
[ ] Ballot #1: Affirmative
[ ] Ballot #1: Negative
[ ] Ballot #1: Abstention
[ ] Ballot #2: Affirmative
[ ] Ballot #2: Negative
[ ] Ballot #2: Abstention
[ ] Ballot #3: Affirmative
[ ] Ballot #3: Negative
[ ] Ballot #3: Abstention
Opening Date Thu, Aug 27 2015 8:00 am Eastern Daylight Time
Closing Date Thu, Sep 10 2015 11:59 pm Eastern Daylight Time
Ballot has closed.
Up to 3 options may be chosen.

Referenced Items

Name Type Date Actions

03437: STRAW BALLOT for NSF 391.1 – Economic or Governance

Document (Archive)

2015-09-11

No Access

Focus on organizations not corporations in NSF International 391_1 Standard (2).pdf

Document

2015-08-26

Duke Energy ESG Report GMI Ratings 05132014.pdf

Document

2015-08-26

No Access

Economic or Governance.pdf

Document

2015-08-26


- Voting Results

Voting Statistics

Number of votes cast (excluding abstentions) 17
Eligible members who have voted 17 of 22 77.273%
Eligible members who have not voted 5 of 22 22.727%

Voting Summary by Option

Options with highest number of votes are bold
Option # Votes % of Total
Ballot #1: Affirmative 2 3.922%
Ballot #1: Negative w/comment 13 25.49%
Ballot #1: Abstention 2 3.922%
Ballot #2: Affirmative 12 23.529%
Ballot #2: Negative w/comment 4 7.843%
Ballot #2: Abstention 1 1.961%
Ballot #3: Affirmative 5 9.804%
Ballot #3: Negative w/comment 8 15.686%
Ballot #3: Abstention 4 7.843%

Voting Summary by Interest Category

Interest CategoryBallot #1: AffirmativeBallot #1: Negative w/commentBallot #1: AbstentionBallot #2: AffirmativeBallot #2: Negative w/commentBallot #2: AbstentionBallot #3: AffirmativeBallot #3: Negative w/commentBallot #3: AbstentionNot Returned
Academia / NGO0000000000
Distributor0000000000
Emeritus0000000000
Fabricator/Formulator0000000000
General Interest0000000000
Government0000000000
Industry2615404321
Ingredient Supplier0000000000
Manufacturer0000000000
Manufacturer Processes0000000000
Medicine/Health0000000000
Non-voting Liaison0000000000
Other0000000000
Other Industry0000000000
Practitioner/Service Provider0000000000
Product Certifier / Testing Lab0000000000
Public Health / Regulatory0505000411
Purchasers & Ecolabel Criteria Users0000000000
Sustainability Advocate & Gov0000000000
Trade Association0000000000
User0212011113
Water Utility0000000000
Not Specified0000000000
Total213212415845