Public Workspaces

Title 3i6r2 Post-sanitizing Rinse Adjudication
Description
This is an adjudication ballot. Not all negative votes cast in the original vote were successfully adjudicated. If you find these negative votes and comments persuasive, this is your opportunity to change your vote in the original ballot.  

This adjudication ballot addresses comments submitted regarding proposed modification conflicting with the Food Code. This issue was presented to the Conference for Food Protection (CFP) in April of 2008. The CFP issued a recommendation to the FDA to revise the FOOD CODE to allow a post-sanitizing, potable water rinse for mechanical warewashers. 

Other comments included:
•	Conflicts with state regulations
•	Increased water usage
•	Facility space requirements
•	Expanded drying time and additional ware storage space for drying
•	Introduction of excess water in the kitchen environment that may result in injury
•	Boil water advisories and the introduction of an after rinse
•	Likelihood that an operator will resort to drying practices that do not comply with Section 4-901.11 of the FDA Food Code 
•	Increased chances for contamination of clean utensils and equipment prior to use
•	Validity of the sanitization efficacy performance criteria & test methods in 6.2 for machines that apply a post-sanitizing rinse. 
•	Effective delivery of sanitizer to all parts of cleaned equipment and utensils, which may take place, via draining, after application of the sanitizing rinse has stopped;
•	Informed selection of available commercial chemical sanitizers, which are typically registered by EPA for use without a rinse after application 
•	Ability of operators and regulatory officials to verify that all parts of cleaned equipment and utensils have been subject to a process that delivers sanitization.

For more information on the comments and the exact text of the final recommendation of the 2008 Conference, see referenced documents.

NOTE - Comments received outside of the scope of the adjudication ballot will be considered non-germane and documented and considered in the same manner as a new proposal.

If you find the comments expressed by the negative voters persuasive, you should vote “no” on this ballot. If you do not find the comments expressed by the negatives voters persuasive, you should vote “yes” on this ballot.  If you do not cast a vote on this ballot, your original vote will carry over.
Ballot Options Ballot has closed
[ ] Affirmative
[ ] Negative w/Comment
[ ] Abstain
Document for Approval 3i6r2.pdf
Opening Date Thu, Jan 8 2009 12:30 pm Eastern Standard Time
Closing Date Thu, Jan 8 2009 2:42 pm Eastern Standard Time
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items

Name Type Date Actions

00633: 3i6r2 Post-sanitizing Rinse Adjudication

Document (Archive)

2009-01-08

No Access

3i6r2-JC-memo-ADJ.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

CFP 2008 Result - Potable Water Rinse.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

JC-FE-3-13-2007-Meeting-Summary-Excerpt.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

4-26-07-Teleconference-summary.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

11-28-07-Teleconference-summary.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Carotenuto-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Coleman-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Drew-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Gagliardi-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Gale-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Kohler-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Nakamura-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Nordin-5-29-08.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

ST-Hipp-Smith-5-29-2008.pdf

Document (Reference Document)

2009-01-08

No Access

- Voting Results

Voting Statistics

Number of votes cast (excluding abstentions) 2
Eligible members who have voted 3 of 33 9.091%
Eligible members who have not voted 30 of 33 90.909%

Voting Summary by Option

Options with highest number of votes are bold
Option # Votes % of Total
Affirmative 1 50%
Negative w/Comment 1 50%
Abstain 1

Voting Summary by Interest Category

Interest CategoryAffirmativeNegative w/CommentAbstainNot ReturnedTotal
Academia / NGO00000 (0%)
Distributor00000 (0%)
Emeritus00000 (0%)
Fabricator/Formulator00000 (0%)
General Interest00000 (0%)
Government00000 (0%)
Industry101911 (33.333%)
Ingredient Supplier00000 (0%)
Manufacturer00000 (0%)
Manufacturer Processes00000 (0%)
Medicine/Health00000 (0%)
Non-voting Liaison00000 (0%)
Other00000 (0%)
Other Industry00000 (0%)
Practitioner/Service Provider00000 (0%)
Product Certifier / Testing Lab00000 (0%)
Public Health / Regulatory0101011 (33.333%)
Purchasers & Ecolabel Criteria Users00000 (0%)
Sustainability Advocate & Gov00000 (0%)
Trade Association00000 (0%)
User0001111 (33.333%)
Water Utility00000 (0%)
Not Specified00000 (0%)
Total1113033 (100%)