Joint Committee on Environmental Leadership Standard for Servers

Document Actions  

Document:
JC Memo and Ballot - 426i1r1 - New Standard.pdf

Draft (A preliminary sketch, outline, or version.)

Details

Submitted By Susan Cruden on 2015-04-17 4:28 pm Coordinated Universal Time

Publication Type

None at this time.

Group / Folder

Joint Committee on Environmental Leadership Standard for Servers / Ballot Documents / 2015 Ballots / Ballots / 426i1r1 - ELSS Ballot

Modified by

Not modified.

Copy

This document is not a copy.

Technical Contact

None at this time.

Download Count

2109

Commenting

Comments can be added by
Group Members
Comments can be viewed by
Group Members

Download Agreement

None at this time.

Description

None at this time.


Comments

Showing 161 of 161 comments
Subject#StateSubmitterDateAction
Support requirements, but would prefer a "simpler" standard0NewNeil Peters-Michaud2015-05-22Details
publically available record of the reuse0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
consultatio for recyclabilty rate0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Functionality testing software tools0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Reference to Annex D in 7.2.10NewPamela Brody-Heine2015-05-22Details
Information and Reporting in preparation for Reuse.....0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
13.4.2 - clarify "support and participation"0NewPatty Dillon2015-05-22Details
13.1.3 - Add EMAS0NewPatty Dillon2015-05-22Details
Annex A - title of 7.2.10NewPamela Brody-Heine2015-05-22Details
12.1.2 strike "CENELEC" in 4th bullet0NewPamela Brody-Heine2015-05-22Details
Product recyclability calculation0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Editorial comment for 6.3.50NewPamela Brody-Heine2015-05-22Details
Design for Plastic recycling0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
12.1.3 - Certified EMS - barrier for small companies0NewPatty Dillon2015-05-22Details
Defintion of semiconductor manufacturing tools0NewPamela Brody-Heine2015-05-22Details
8.1.4 - define "normal operation"0NewPatty Dillon2015-05-22Details
8.1.2 - define non-resable or delete0NewPatty Dillon2015-05-22Details
Design for repair, reuse and recycling0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Section 5.3.2 additional criterion0NewBill Tschudi2015-05-22Details
Document References0NewBill Tschudi2015-05-22Details
Comments on draft standard NSF 4260NewTim Mann2015-05-22Details
Optimization of packagin gsystem to reduce excess packaging0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
External Enclosure0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Comments on NSF 4260NewShigetaka Seki2015-05-22Details
Definition- Cosmetic blank/dummy0NewPatty Dillon2015-05-22Details
Negative Vote on NSF 4260NewTim Earl2015-05-22Details
GHG Emissions0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Feedback on NSF 4260NewMichael Kirschner2015-05-22Details
Mass vs. weight0NewPatty Dillon2015-05-22Details
Comments on several sections in attached file - JC Memo and Ball0NewWayne Rifer2015-05-22Details
clarifying evidence in verification required in 7.2.20NewWayne Rifer2015-05-22Details
5.2.3 Reduce Energy Loss from Conversion0NewJinshui Liu2015-05-22Details
5.2.1 80 Plus Program0NewJinshui Liu2015-05-22Details
Comments for Proposed Standard0NewCatherine Ho2015-05-22Details
5.1.1 ENERGY STAR Compliance Table 5.10NewJinshui Liu2015-05-22Details
Annex C - chemical lists0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Toxics reporting0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Social responsibility0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Conflict minerals0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Life cycle assessment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Preparation for reuse and recycling0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Cl in packaging0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
External enclosures0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Fluorinated GHG emissions0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Alternatives assessment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Alternatives assessment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Alternatives assessment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Alternatives assessment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Alternatives assessment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Alternatives assessment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Full substance inventory0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Full substance inventory0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Full substance inventory0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Candidate SVHCs0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Br and Cl restrictions0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Br and Cl restrictions0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
Idle state power0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
General comment0NewSteve Risotto2015-05-22Details
General Comments0NewChris Cleet2015-05-22Details
Reductio of substances on the EU REACH SVHC list0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Reduction of Br and Cl content of plastic parts - test method0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Reduction of Br and Cl content of plastic parts0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Cables should be exclude like Printed wired boards are0NewPaul Parkinson2015-05-22Details
Logged Server Activities0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
80 Plus Program0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
Annex C0NewRalph Buoniconti2015-05-22Details
defining conflict free0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
commonly available tolols0NewWilliam Hoffman2015-05-22Details
7.1.1 - External enclosure0NewRalph Buoniconti2015-05-22Details
6.3.4 – Alternatives Assessment0NewRalph Buoniconti2015-05-22Details
6.3.3 – Acquiring substance inventory0NewRalph Buoniconti2015-05-22Details
6.3.2 – Requesting full substance inventory0NewRalph Buoniconti2015-05-22Details
6.1.4 Reduction of Br and Cl content of plastic parts0NewRalph Buoniconti2015-05-22Details
Comments on the NSF 426 draft Server Standard0NewRichard Krock2015-05-21Details
Definitions0NewRichard Krock2015-05-21Details
General Remarks0NewRichard Krock2015-05-21Details
Comments on several sections in attached file0NewWayne Rifer2015-05-21Details
Use of "primary circuit board"0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Self reference in 11.2.10NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Point language in 11.2.30NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Interpretation of function in 9.1.40NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Vague language in 9.1.40NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Starting language in 9.1.40NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Location of point information in 8.3.1c0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Maintaining prereqs/optional points over time0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Remove limitation on source of PCR for 7.2.20NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Possible word missing from 6.4.10NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Pluralize suppliers in 6.4.10NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Location of disclosure in 6.3.10NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Connect 5.3.1 to product0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Extra verbiage in 5.2.10NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Title is pluralized0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Use of "performance tier" in 5.1.30NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Location of "printed circuit board" in definitions0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Applicability of 12.1.3 unclear0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Use of term "objective evidence"0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Use of undefined term "fractions" in 9.1.30NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Mismatch in requirements in 8.3.1b0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Require LCA methodology for 8.3.1b0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Consider definition for "supply chain management" terms0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Testing requirement for 5.3.20NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Need ES version number in criterion 5.3.20NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Unnecessary justification for criterion 5.3.20NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Definition of "recyclable" open-ended0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Need consistent terminology for public disclosure on a website0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Broaden definition of disposal0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Treatment is not disposal0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Definition of reuse is to limiting0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Differentiating titles of 13.2.2 and 13.2.30NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Table heading and indicator titles in Table 13.10NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
Clarify definition of scope 2 to align with GRI0NewCate Berard2015-05-21Details
13.5.2 Certification to social responsibility performance standa0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.5.2 Certification to social responsibility performance standa0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.5.1 Supply chain certification to occupational health and saf0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.4.1 CM sourced from only validated conflict free smelters0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.4.1 CM sourced from only validated conflict free smelters0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.4.1 CM sourced from only validated conflict free smelters0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.4.1 CM sourced from only validated conflict free smelters0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.4 Conflict minerals sourcing0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.4 Conflict minerals sourcing0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.3 Reporting Toxics Release Data0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.2.3 Envtl and social responsibility reporting on tier 1 suppl0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.2.3 Envtl and social responsibility reporting on tier 1 suppl0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.2.2 Envtl and social responsibility on supply chain – 9 splrs0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.2.2 Envtl and social responsibility on supply chain – 9 splrs0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.1.2 Public disclosure of use of conflict minerals in products0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13.1.2 Public disclosure of use of conflict minerals in products0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
13 Corporate social responsibility0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
11.2.1 Conduct life cycle assessment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
11.2.1 Conduct life cycle assessment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
11.2.1 Conduct life cycle assessment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.3.4 Alternatives assessment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.3.4 Alternatives assessment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.3.4 Alternatives assessment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.3.4 Alternatives assessment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.3.3 Acquiring substance inventory0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.3.2 Requesting full substance inventory0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.3.1 Disclosure of declarable substances0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.2.1 Reduction of substances on the EU REACH Regulation0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.2.1 Reduction of substances on the EU REACH Regulation0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.2.1 Reduction of substances on the EU REACH Regulation0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.1.4 Reduction of bromine and chlorine content of plastic parts0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.1.4 Reduction of bromine and chlorine content of plastic parts0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.1.4 Reduction of bromine and chlorine content of plastic parts0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.1.3 Inventory of declarable substances0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.1.3 Inventory of declarable substances0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
6.1.1 Conformance with EU RoHS Directive0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
Section 6.1.1 Conformance with EU RoHS Directive0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
Section 60NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
Definitions0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
General Comment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
General Comment0NewStephanie Voyles2015-05-20Details
Product longevity0NewJonathan Wood2015-05-19Details
Energy efficiency - additional aspects to consider0NewJonathan Wood2015-05-19Details
Batteries Directive labelling requirements0NewJonathan Wood2015-05-19Details
12.1.1 and 12.2.1 differences0NewJonathan Wood2015-05-19Details
Life Cycle Assessment Methodology0NewJonathan Wood2015-05-19Details
Reference to 9.2.10NewJonathan Wood2015-05-19Details
Information and Reporting: Increased ambition0NewJonathan Wood2015-05-19Details
About criteria Energy0NewFrançoise Berthoud2015-05-19Details
EPA Comments0NewHolly Elwood2015-05-18Details