Public Workspaces

Comment 12173
New (Unresolved)
DRAFT_GEC_ESG Criteria Document_1Dec2023_Redline Changes for Public Comment_v2.pdf (Revision 1)
Comment Submitted by
Kazuhito Oosumi
2024-01-15 00:15:58

The following is described in “References and details”.

 

1) RBA’s Code of Conduct Version 7.0 meet the manufacturer’s commitment elements of this criterion and RBA’s Risk Assessment Platform in combination with Self-Assessment Questionnaire (SAQ) is an analysis methodology meeting the identification of Prioritized Manufacturer Facilities of “Part A. Assessment for to Determining Determine Prioritized Manufacturer Facilities in Scope.”  

The above is one of the important methods for RBA member companies to demonstrate their conformance to the requirements.  We think that the above should be described as evidence for proof in the “Verification requirements”.

 

2) RBA Code of Conduct has been updated to 8.0 in 2024 January, therefore, we request to clearly mention subsequent versions will be applied in order to avoid confusion or additional explanation required about version of RBA code.

 

Submitter Proposed Solution

For 7.1.1;

The following description in “References and details” should be moved to “Verification requirements” of Part A, and subsequent version of RBA’s Code of Conduct needs to be added.

 

a) URL(s) for publicly available manufacturer commitment to meeting the requirements of this criterion on manufacturer’s website. [ADD: RBA’s Code of Conduct Version 7.0 and/or subsequent versions (including 8.0) meet the manufacturer’s commitment elements of this criterion.]

 

[ADD: h) Demonstrating RBA membership and conducting the assessment using RBA’s Risk Assessment Platform in combination with Self-Assessment Questionnaire (SAQ) is acceptable evidence for conformance to all of Part A Verification requirements.]

 

We believe the above-mentioned methodology should be evidence for at least, b), e) and f) of the “Verification requirements”.

 

For 7.1.2;

References and details” also refer to “RBA’s Code of Conduct”. As mentioned above, “RBA’s Code of Conduct” should be moved from “References and details” to “Verification requirements” by adding d) as follows:

 

[ADD: d) RBA’s Code of Conduct, Version 7.0 and/or subsequent versions (including 8.0) meet the elements of this criterion.]

 

 

For 7.1.3;

The following description in “References and details” should be moved to “Verification requirements”:

 

“RBA’s Risk Assessment Platform in combination with Self-Assessment Questionnaire (SAQ) is recognized as an analysis methodology meeting the identification Prioritized Supplier Facilities of “Part A. Assessment for to Determining Determine Prioritized Supplier Facilities in Scope.”

 

We propose to change the description of “a) of Part A” in “Verification requirements” as follows:

 

a) Documentation of process to identify Prioritized Supplier Facilities that demonstrates conformity to this criterion. [ADD: RBA’s Risk Assessment Platform in combination with Self-Assessment Questionnaire (SAQ) is recognized as an analysis methodology meeting the identification Prioritized Supplier Facilities of “Part A. Assessment for to Determining Determine Prioritized Supplier Facilities in Scope.]