Public Workspaces

Comment 13535
Assigned (Unresolved)
40i62r2 et al - Alternate Methods - JC Memo & Ballot.pdf (Revision 0)
Approval of 40i62r2 et al - Alternate Methods
Comment Submitted by
Jim Meyer
2025-08-11 10:53:51

I think that adding additional approved methods is a great idea, but this language is open to interpretation. The language indicates a lab can validate a test method themselves as being equivalent. I think it would be much better to just list the approved test methods in the standard. Perhaps NSF can poll the labs and ask for a list of test methods they would like to have added as alternates. Assuming the methods were from a valid agency like EPA, or already accepted by a body such as NELAP, we could add the methods into the standards.

Submitter Proposed Solution

Add alternate test methods to standards that have already been vetted by an accredited organization.

Shannon McCormick
2025-08-11 3:35 pm Eastern Daylight Time

Hi Jim,

Please see the recent attachment to this ballot with a list of responses to the comments on the R1 ballot.

40i62r1 et al - Alternate Methods - Comment Summary with responses.pdf

Please respond by Friday, August 15 and let me know if this additional information addresses your comment and you would like to change your vote to a yes, or maintain the negative vote.

Thank you,

Shannon McCormick, NSF, Secretariat