Public Workspaces

Title Approval of 14i58r1 Stress corrosion
Description
On behalf of Ata Ciechanowski, Issue proponent, the ballot for NSF/ANSI 14, issue 58, revision 1, Stress Corrosion Resistance has been recommended to be sent to the Joint Committee for consideration.  Please review the proposal and return your ballot by the ballot due date of April 2 1014 via the online workspace (http://standards.nsf.org).

When adding comments, please identify the section number/name for your comment and add all comments under one comment number where possible.  If you need additional space, please upload a word or pdf version of your comments online via the browse function.

Purpose

The purpose of this ballot is to clarify the pass/fail criteria for stress corrosion resistance in section 5.8.2.3 of NSF 14 by excluding hairline surface fracture of a certain size that could occur because of machining or casting. Currently any crack when viewed through a 10X microscope constitute a failure including hairline surface cracks.
Ballot Options Ballot has closed
[ ] Affirmative
[ ] Negative
[ ] Abstain
Document for Approval 14i58r1 Stress corrosion.pdf
Opening Date Wed, Mar 12 2014 3:00 pm Eastern Daylight Time
Closing Date Wed, Apr 2 2014 11:59 pm Eastern Daylight Time
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items

Name Type Date Actions

02750: Approval of 14i58r1 Stress corrosion

Document (Archive)

2014-04-03

JC Memo 14i58r1.pdf

Document

2014-03-12

No Access

PLAS 2013-10 - SCC.pdf

Document

2014-03-12

No Access

PLAS 2013-10s - SCC section 5.8.pdf

Document

2014-03-12

No Access

PLAS JC meeting summary 2013 excerpt Stress Corrosion resistance.pdf

Document

2014-03-12

No Access

- Voting Results

Voting Statistics

Number of votes cast (excluding abstentions) 14
Eligible members who have voted 19 of 21 90.476%
Eligible members who have not voted 2 of 21 9.524%

Voting Summary by Option

Options with highest number of votes are bold
Option # Votes % of Total
Affirmative 13 92.857%
Negative w/comment 1 7.143%
Abstain 5

Voting Summary by Interest Category

Interest CategoryAffirmativeNegative w/commentAbstainNot ReturnedTotal
Academia / NGO00000 (0%)
Distributor00000 (0%)
Emeritus00000 (0%)
Fabricator/Formulator00000 (0%)
General Interest00000 (0%)
Government00000 (0%)
Industry514010 (47.619%)
Ingredient Supplier00000 (0%)
Manufacturer00000 (0%)
Manufacturer Processes00000 (0%)
Medicine/Health00000 (0%)
Non-voting Liaison00000 (0%)
Other00000 (0%)
Other Industry00000 (0%)
Practitioner/Service Provider00000 (0%)
Product Certifier / Testing Lab00000 (0%)
Public Health / Regulatory20013 (14.286%)
Purchasers & Ecolabel Criteria Users00000 (0%)
Sustainability Advocate & Gov00000 (0%)
Trade Association00000 (0%)
User60118 (38.095%)
Water Utility00000 (0%)
Not Specified00000 (0%)
Total1315221 (100%)