Public Workspaces

Comment 459
Rejected (Unresolved)
61i79r1.pdf (Revision 0)
Approval of 61i79r1 (Annex G - lead content criteria)
Comment Submitted by
Robert Powell
2008-05-14 10:22:13
Current information regarding health effects of very low exposures to lead does not support classifying Annex G as a health standard. The LTG memo states that it is "difficult to discern true cause and effect" of very low lead exposure. In fact, no such cause and effect determination at very low levels has, at this point, been shown. The LTG writes "eliminating potential exposure to lead as a potential contributor to these health effects seems to be a health standard." NSF standards should be based on firmly supported information rather than "potentials" that lead to what "seems to be a health standard." Resources should be expended to accomplish real goals supported by solid information.
Submitter Proposed Solution
Do not include Annex G at this time. Inclusion of lead content criteria should be re-considered if information demonstrating health effects at very low exposure levels is available.
Developer Response
Please see the attachment for the response to your comments. A reply indicating your intent to either change or maintain your vote is appreciated on or before July 4, 2008. If no response is received, we will assume that you are maintaining your negative.
Supporting File: Agness-Powell-response.pdf